BackThe Blacksmiths Arms, Biggin, Leeds, West Yorkshire
Reviews Page
The Blacksmiths Arms, Biggin, Leeds, West Yorkshire has been reviewed 19 times and has an overall rating of 58 points out of a possible 95, or 61.05% positive feedback.
| The Blacksmiths Arms, Biggin, Leeds, West Yorkshire has Fairly Good Rating |  |
|
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Review |
| 26/09/2010 21:31:01 | Sally |  |
| When this establishment re-opened after a 2 year absence when the kingfisher failed, we were excited. To begin with the food was good but the service was slow. We'd wait 35 minutes between starter and main courses even though only 2 out of our table of 6 had starters. After finnishing our main course the waitress asked us not if we wanted dessert and coffee, but could we vacate to the bar area as they wanted the table back for someone else.....shocking when considering how slow these people operate. We gave them various other chances however the last straw came when we went for a mid-week lunch to see that the price for their decent but not outstanding menu had gone up for the 2nd time in a short period (fish n chips had gone up to £12....OMG) Although the food is above average, it is not worth the price they charge. On all accounts they've lost a lot of custom due to overcharging....You can get a better fish n chips at the castle pub in cawood for £7.50!! To begin with we were going nearly every week for lunch or dinner as we live in Biggin but since they appear to put crazy profit margins before customer satisfaction we now drive out and enjoy fairer priced but good meals eleswhere. [Report for Removal] | Sally Biggin N.Yorks |
|
| 17/09/2010 11:58:38 | Tom and Ann Jones |  |
| We have eaten here several times this year , lucky enough to have been twice in this last week, once for the early Bird and the second for an al acarte. The food and service is consistantly very good. about 15 to 20 tableS with diners at 6.30 on a Thursday tells me others think the same. It is not the cheapest place to eat , but you get what you pay for, you definitely do here[Report for Removal] | Tom and Ann Jones Sherburn in Elmet North Yorkshire |
|
| 26/08/2010 14:34:05 | Trev Phillips | |
| This is an excellent pub. We live about 6 miles away but make the journey regularly. Whilst retaining a lovely 'local pub' atmosphere they offer a wide menu of imaginitive dishes cooked and prepared to a high standard. Not cheap, but not expensive and very fairly priced for the quality. If you want a plate piled high with basic sausage mash and chips this isn't the place for you. Service is informal but friendly and effecient and the quality of customer care in our experience cannot be faulted. Highly recommended for a pleasant drink among friendly locals, or a really nice informal meal out. [Report for Removal] | Trev Phillips Monk Fryston N. Yorks |
|
| 15/04/2010 15:47:19 | Mrs Dunhelm | |
| Review hidden, pending approval.[Report for Removal] | Mrs Dunhelm Leeds North Yorkshire |
|
| 03/03/2010 11:28:28 | Richard Singh | |
| I’m very surprised to hear of some bad experience at The Blacksmiths Arms – Biggin. I have been there on numerous occasions and had found the staff, food and service to be first class. We booked our table and were seated as soon as we arrived. We even failed to book once and they explained we could have a table, but we would have to make sure we were clear within the hour as the table we were going to use had already been pre booked. Not a problem, when people are honest with you, you respect it. The food is of a higher price, but you don’t mind paying a bit extra for quality food. Like I say first class and we will definitely be returning [Report for Removal] | Richard Singh SELBY NORTH YORKSHIRE |
|
| 16/01/2010 12:46:42 | Dorian Wilmore | |
| Was discussing this pub with a friends the other day and he commented on the negative comments by some people on Internet sites, have read all the above/below comments all i can say is some people expect the earth from what is in fact a country pub. i and my family and friends have been visiting this pub since opening. What i can say is yes at the start their were a few teething problems as staff were being trained and the landlord and chef got the place to where it is now. the place is very friendly, welcoming, has a down to earth atmosphere and serves some of the best food in Yorkshire that for the quality is no way over priced. The mark of a good eating house is usually how full it is at prime times. if you want to try the Blacksmiths book well in advance as Friday Saturday evenings and Sunday afternoons are extremely busy. due to this sometimes there is a wait for food but when a chef will not compromise quality by cooking from fresh every day without buying in pre prepared rubbish then i would rather wait. 12 months on this pub just gets better. Great Food great beer and down to earth friendly staff. even if they do call you Love !! well done the Smiths.[Report for Removal] | Dorian Wilmore Leeds West Yorkshire |
|
| 14/01/2010 19:57:04 | Ross Macdonald | |
| Eaten here many times with family, friends and business customers - never had a complaint. The food is excellent, choice is superb, the staff are very friendly and courteous. Not the cheapest but for thsi quality of food and environment I wouldn't expect it to be.[Report for Removal] | Ross Macdonald Selby North Yorkshire |
|
| 18/07/2009 22:57:43 | David Fryer | |
| An early Friday lunchtime visit after over 20 years to the building was met with cheery staff, and a more than welcoming chef who described the specials of the day, two of which were sampled and were excellent. Obvioulsy freshly prepared and cooked. A few too many ladies decorating the bar conducting personal mobile phone conversations, and which could have been done without. The toilets were imacculate even though one had to negotiate a childs high chair en-route, and there were a few too many flies buzzing around the bar area. Having said that, I will certailny be going back again as these minor failings were well compensated for by the quality of food and service from one of the most cheerful waitresses I have seen for many years Good luck for the future, you obviously have the makings of a very successful business if the standards of food and service can be maintained and from reading earlier comments, can be improved upon in some areas. [Report for Removal] | David Fryer Leeds Yorks |
|
| 12/07/2009 12:51:07 | Anne & Steve Eastman | |
| Having been so impressed during our first visit, we were invited to visit again with some friends living in the area. The standard of food and service, on a busy Saturday night, was to the same, very high standard as 3 months ago. Everything about this pub is "spot on" and the food came quickly and was piping hot. The mussels were the best we had seen & tasted in ages, and the sauteéd kidneys were cooked to perfection. The Sea Bass and Scallops as a main course was also superb, and with a very acceptable bottle of house wine, and enjoyable company, every Saturday night should be like this! We really hope they can maintain the very high standard they have set.[Report for Removal] | Anne & Steve Eastman Wetherby West Yorks |
|
| 16/06/2009 16:04:34 | Sandra and Julian Platt | |
| We have visited the Blacksmiths Arms on several occasions since it re-opened in December 2008. It has become a pleasant habit if we are out after work mid-week to drop by for a drink on the way home. Whether we are there for a drink in the cosy bar, having lunch with family or dinner with friends we have always had excellent and friendly service. The food has been superb on every occasion. The decor is perfectly fitting to such an old building and the atmosphere has always been very good. We only wish it was within walking distance![Report for Removal] | Sandra and Julian Platt Wistow North Yorkshire |
|
| 25/04/2009 23:41:57 | Steve Eastman | |
| Four of us had a lovely meal, and a very enjoyable evening, on a very busy Saturday night. The food and service was exceptional - the rack of lamb was to die for and was worth the half an hour wait, that we were warned it would take. The wine and beer was excellent and the atmosphere was busy but under control. Pubs like this seem harder and harder to find these days. It's a place we would really like to return to as we were very, very impressed.[Report for Removal] | Steve Eastman Wetherby West Yorks |
|
| 25/04/2009 19:16:20 | Mr P Linley |  |
| Three of us went on a Saturday lunchtime and we thought the food was way over-priced for what we received. We were given a disappointingly small amount of vegetables and had to ask for more. Even then it was only made up of shredded cabbage and celery. Not good enough when you are paying premium prices on a lunchtime. The place lacked both charm and atmosphere. I have been to the Blacksmith's some years ago under different ownership and the place has certainly deteriorated.[Report for Removal] | Mr P Linley Leeds West Yorkshire |
|
| 08/04/2009 14:08:14 | Keith | |
| Went for Sunday Lunch.Reservation for 12noon.First class service, excellent meal (there were 6 of us)However the landlord I think could have done with a shave[Report for Removal] | Keith Leeds West Yorks |
|
| 20/03/2009 08:08:19 | Ray Wild |  |
| Went a week ago for lunch with two friends. All our meals were excellent even though my belly pork was quite small for a main course. Beer excellent as was the service apart from being called "darling" all the time by the lady behind the bar![Report for Removal] | Ray Wild Plonevez du Faou Finistere, Brittany |
|
| 17/03/2009 16:25:57 | margaret hartley | |
| We went to the Blacksmiths Arms for our wedding anniversary as a party of 4. The welcome was fantastic - the food terrific - the service excellent. The atmosphere was conducive to good eating and mine hosts were convivial and charming. Thank you for making 26 years of marriage worth the work![Report for Removal] | margaret hartley leeds west yorkshire |
|
| 06/03/2009 11:27:56 | claire | |
| Ecvellent food, beer and servis! could have not asked for a nicer dinning experiance![Report for Removal] | claire leeds north yorks |
|
| 26/01/2009 12:59:26 | John Warburton |  |
| I concur with Mr Lakin regarding the service at the Blacksmiths arms. I have never had such a bad experience of service in my life. The excuse was that the owners are new and have teething problems. I actually believe they have no understanding of the hospitality industry. To ignore bookings and not to put reserved on a table that had been booked by my party is a disgrace. I also will not be returning to the establishment - what a shame especially as the beer is good.[Report for Removal] | John Warburton Selby North Yorkshire |
|
| 24/01/2009 14:00:56 | Albert Lakin | |
| The food was OK but not worth the wait. There’s one word to describe the service and management of this establishment and that is abysmal. Don’t bother making a reservation because it doesn’t mean a thing the greedy management will simply let your table go to the first available punter even if you are on time. We (a party of six) booked our table for 8.30pm on the 23 Jan 09 and finally received our food at 10.20pm and to top it all had to eat in the bar area because the restaurant was full. We where all there in good time for our table. One hour after ordering our food we where told that two dishes where no longer available and would have to choose two alternative dishes. In my opinion this dreadful service is down to one thing and that is the greed of the management who appear to be interested only in lining their own pockets rather than giving any consideration to customer satisfaction. Despite giving an apology they completely ruined our evening. There is one thing for sure, and that is we will never give our custom to this establishment again. In a service industry, establishments operating like this do not deserve to remain in business, there are plenty out there prepared to pamper to your every whim.[Report for Removal] | Albert Lakin Wakefield West Yorkshire |
|
| 03/12/2008 20:40:43 | r.tunnicliffe | |
| the blacksmiths has recently undergone a fantastic revamp, and now offers a very warm and friendly atmosphere which welcomes children aswell. it offers traditional fine ales, lagers, and extensive wine list. it offers a wide range of food including tradidional sunday lunch, sensational sea food meals such as sea-bass,prawns and muscles to name a few. all the food is freshly made and all to very high standards. the staff are friendly, welcoming and proffesional. my family and i reccomend a visit to the pub at your earliest oppertunity. just to say thanks again to Jim and Jo for a very enjoyable sunday afternoon, the first of many![Report for Removal] | r.tunnicliffe byram north yorkshire |
|
Add a Review for The Blacksmiths Arms, Biggin, Leeds, West Yorkshire
These reviews are the comments of individual visitors to Pubsulike and should not be taken as the views of Pubsulike - publishers of this web site. However if you feel a review should be removed or investigated please let us know by using the [Report for Removal] link.